Black heel sandal versus black and tan Mia Vita sandal, split by a VS badge

The Magazine Winner vs The Mia Vita Match

The magazines crowned their favourites.
I found the Mia Vita that walks the same brief.

Right then. Half my group chat lately is just me, firing off links like it is breaking news. An editor at Glamour crowning a wedding heel. A podiatrist co-signing a ballet flat over at Real Simple. Good Housekeeping ranking the comfiest heels like there is a trophy on the line. Award-season behaviour, and I am absolutely seated.

Quick confession before we start, because we have all been there. I have walked out the door in a shoe that looked unreal and completely turned on me by the second coffee. The whole point of this page is the look you actually want next to the day you actually have. No trade-off.

Here is the fun bit. Every shoe those editors crowned, we already stock at The Comfort Co. We also make a few of our own under Mia Vita that quietly handle the very same brief. I lined them up so you can see it yourself, the crowned winner beside our match, occasion by occasion. Each crown links to the magazine that handed it out, each shoe links to its page, then you get to play judge.

Dee Riediger, Resident Style Editor at The Comfort Co

Dee Riediger

Lead Social & Email Marketing Specialist / Resident Style Editor, The Comfort Co

A fashion photographer of over eight years who can style a look from the school gate to a dinner without changing shoes.

The wedding heel

The brief. A heel you can actually dance in long past the speeches, that still photographs like an occasion.

Naturalizer Vera heeled dress sandal, named best heel for weddings by Glamour

The magazine crown

Naturalizer Vera

Best heel for weddings, per Glamour1, E! Online2 and Good Housekeeping3

A cushioned footbed and a slip-resistant sole hide under a tidy block heel. That is how the editors landed on it for the reception that runs long.

Mia Vita Yass Heeled Sandal in Black Multi, a strappy occasion heel with hidden cushioning

The Mia Vita match

Yass Heeled Sandal

Our take on the occasion heel

A strappy heel with the cushioning built right in, named Yass for good reason. This is your one for the wedding, the work drinks and the lunch that quietly becomes dinner.

The everyday flat

The brief. A flat that finishes the outfit and does not quietly wreck your feet by the afternoon.

Vionic Orinda square-toe ballet flat, named a best supportive ballet flat by BuzzFeed

The magazine crown

Vionic Orinda

A best supportive ballet flat, per BuzzFeed4, Real Simple5 and InStyle6

A square-toe flat with arch support tucked under the leather. BuzzFeed had actual podiatrists vet the contenders, and this one made the cut.

Mia Vita Violet Mary-Jane flat in black, an everyday flat with hidden comfort

The Mia Vita match

Violet Mary-Jane

Our take on the everyday flat

The Mary-Jane strap does the cute, the cushioned footbed handles the long haul. Hand on heart, this is the flat I actually reach for on a real day.

The work slip-on

The brief. Polished enough for the meeting, kind enough for the car-park sprint.

Vionic Uptown Loafer, named a best office shoe by People

The magazine crown

Vionic Uptown Loafer

Best spring office shoe, per People7, and a best slip-on to walk miles in, per Good Housekeeping8

Looks like proper leather, wears like a secret. A contoured footbed with a deep heel cup sits underneath, which is why it keeps making the work lists.

Mia Vita Bridgette slip-on in black leather, an easy-on style for work

The Mia Vita match

Bridgette Slip-On

Our take on the work slip-on

Black leather, no laces, on your feet in a second when the morning is already a write-off. Smart enough for the desk, kind enough for the nine-hour day.

The summer sandal

The brief. A sandal that looks like a holiday and keeps up like a proper shoe, no blisters by lunch.

Vionic Tide toe-post sandal, named a best arch-support sandal by CNN Underscored

The magazine crown

Vionic Tide

A best arch-support sandal, per CNN Underscored9 and Real Simple10

Arch support hides under a toe-post light enough for the beach, which is why it keeps turning up the second the weather warms.

Mia Vita Ayla adjustable sandal in black, an everyday summer sandal with hidden comfort

The Mia Vita match

Ayla Adjustable Sandal

Our take on the summer sandal

Adjustable straps for the feet that swell through a hot day, a soft cushioned footbed underneath. This is your morning-coffee-to-rooftop sandal.

The best part

Here is the genuinely lovely bit. Every shoe on this page lives under one roof at The Comfort Co, the magazine darlings and our own Mia Vita styles, sat on the same shelf. We carry all of them, so this was never about picking sides.

Take the crowned classic, take the Mia Vita, take one of each. Whichever you slip on, you are walking out in something we loved enough to put on the shelf.

Shop the whole line-up

The magazine darlings and our Mia Vita styles, all in one place.

Shop the Best Sellers

References

  1. Glamour. The most comfortable heels for women. glamour.com
  2. E! Online. The most comfortable heels. eonline.com
  3. Good Housekeeping. The most comfortable heels to wear. goodhousekeeping.com
  4. BuzzFeed. Podiatrists helped us find actually supportive ballet flats. buzzfeed.com
  5. Real Simple. Podiatrist-approved ballet flats. realsimple.com
  6. InStyle. Podiatrist-approved shoes on Amazon. instyle.com
  7. People. Podiatrist-approved spring office shoes on Amazon. people.com
  8. Good Housekeeping. Best women's slip-on shoes. goodhousekeeping.com
  9. CNN Underscored. The best arch support sandals. cnn.com
  10. Real Simple. Podiatrist-approved sandals for summer. realsimple.com
Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.